Courts separate mother and child

THE SCENARIO: A woman’s seven-year-old son puts his hand inside his mum’s shirt in public. She is charged with indecent dealing with a minor. Community Services removes the boy. That was in December, 2008.

When the NewsMail reported the court case today, they expected the mother and son to be reunited in two to four weeks.

There are so many variables that I don’t know, but by her own admission she had an issue with boundaries since she was abused as a child.

But for more than three years this child’s been away from his mother. Because he put his hand in her shirt.

That, to me, is terrifying.

That someone can deem an act inappropriate and remove your own child from your care for so long. It’s incredulous when I’ve seen other children suffer much worse neglect at the hands of their parents and their children are returned to them, time and time again.

It saddened me to read of the distress this caused the boy and his mother.

I can’t even begin to imagine.

But I wonder two things: one) was his hand (I hate using this word) groping or merely resting on her breast? And was this a measure of comfort that had been happening for years?

Is it really any different to the small child who hides their face in your lap when they’re embarassed?

That train of thought begs the question that breastfeeding mothers have been arguing for years – what is a breast? It’s not just about sexual objectification. It’s a source of nourishment and comfort and it CAN be a source of fascination to older children.

If the son did this to his dad, the situation would have been very different. So to what extent do women – do mothers – have to defend themselves when it comes to their chest?

Secondly, how do we decide when something is inappropriate? And does it depend on a child’s age? I can understand, if the act really was awkward for those who witnessed it, that they felt obliged to say something, do something. After all, what if something much worse is going on behind closed doors?

It can be incredibly difficult to trust your instinct when it comes to another person’s child. It takes guts to act on your convictions. But what if you’re mistaken?

Three-plus years is a long time for a family to pay the price for a social mishap.

Everything about this story shocked me. But what stuck with my subconscious was the ability to lose your children at the hands of others; of other parents, of the courts and community services.

The night I read this, I dreamt that I’d left my daughter napping in one town as I drove to another. I was meant to put her in the car, but in my haste forgot, and two hours later I was beside the highway, an hysterical mess.

I had no one to call on to check on her before I could get back and I knew I had to ring the police. But what if they considered me a neglectful parent? Would I ever get her back?

I rang the police and they checked on her and they told me they’d take her back to the station with them…. “where I could come pick her up”. I wept with relief.

I’d love to know what others think. Was this action warranted? Would you have reported it? Have you seen anything that you felt needed to be reported? Or have you been reported for something?

 

Digital Parents Blog Carnival

Advertisements

4 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. teamcleo
    Mar 26, 2012 @ 05:51:21

    What a sad thing to happen to the family! I feel that the separation might have done more damage to the poor child than him putting his hand under his mum’s shirt! It’s really sad to know that we don’t have full rights to what’s happening in our own family. But yes, the law is there to take care of children in abusive families. But still, I hope their investigation found enough proof that the boy had to stay away from his mother. 3 years is a long long time. I can’t imagine my son being taken away from me just for a week to live with somebody else!

    Reply

    • petajo
      Mar 26, 2012 @ 07:44:30

      And at such an age – three years is like forever. You’d hope that they’d prevented anything worse from happening and that’s not something we can know.

      Reply

  2. marketingtomilk
    Mar 26, 2012 @ 07:00:27

    I thnk i’d want to know an awful lot more about the court case and family history before commenting tbh. On the surface – no it is utterly ridiculous – my son is forever shoving his hand up my top. But to us my breasts aren’t sexual so there’s no issue. I’d hope most parents could tell the difference.

    M2M

    Reply

    • petajo
      Mar 26, 2012 @ 07:42:56

      I know – it’s hard when we weren’t there. It’s just food for thought, I guess. The consequences of our actions, and such. I wonder if anyone who reported it to authorities actually spoke to the mother first. It could’ve saved them much heartache.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: